The skin around our eyes is delicate—way thinner than the rest of our face and loses moisture 50% faster. From teenage years spent pulling all-nighters to study, to later years where we start noticing wrinkles and saggy bags, our eyes really do show it all. And let’s not forget those under-eye hollows that are often genetic and typically need more than just creams to fix.
Are Eye Creams Just Overpriced Moisturizers?
Here’s the honest truth: a lot of eye creams are basically just fancy moisturizers in smaller jars. Your favorite face cream or oil can often do the same job. But there are some eye products out there that are specially formulated with active ingredients designed for that delicate eye area. Personally, I prefer eye serums for their penetrating power or highly occlusive eye oils for their intense hydration. And eye masks? Absolute lifesavers!
Top Natural and Organic Eye Creams and Serums
1. INNBEAUTY Project Bright & Tight Eye Cream
Best for: Dark circles, hyperpigmentation, and wrinkles
Price: $34
Looking for a clean eye primer? This one doubles as an eye cream and primer. Packed with actives like 3 types of Vitamin C, 3% Tranexamic Acid, Bakuchiol, Peptides, NovoRetin, and Caffeine, this cream helps brighten dark circles and smooth wrinkles. It’s light yet moisturizing and even offers a bit of coverage.
2. Sunday Riley Auto Correct Eye Cream
Best for: Depuffing, brightening, and smoothing
Price: $65.00
Auto Correct contains caffeine and light reflecting particles to banish the appearance of tired looking eyes. It instantly delivers a brightened, lifted and depuffed look to the eye area and reduces appearance of dark circles. Delivers a lifted & depuffed look to the eye area while reducing the appearance of dark circles and fine lines. Apply one to two pumps AM and PM. Use your ring and middle fingers, lightly tap into the skin around the eye area.
3. Beekman 1802 Mushroom Milk Better Aging Eye Cream
Best for: Dark circles, fine lines, and wrinkles
Bundle Price: $150
Beekman 1802 skincare products are cruelty-free and vegan. Mushroom Milk Better Aging eye cream has a milky, whipped texture that’s just divine. The mushroom milk is designed to hydrate and nourish the skin. It contains natural ingredients like mushroom extract and squalane that help to improve skin’s appearance and texture. It’s formulated with a variety of actives like 5% Hexapeptide, Goat Milk, Lion’s Mane for crow’s feet, Snow Mushroom to cool and depuff, Reishi Mushroom to lift and firm, Kojic Acid Fungi Ferment to brighten, and Sclerotium Fungi to hydrate. While it’s on the pricier side, its undisputed effectiveness makes it worth every penny.
4. OSEA Ocean Eyes Age-Defying Serum
Best for: Dark circles, fine lines, puffiness, and crow’s feet
Price: $58
This serum is refreshing and cooling, thanks to its metal roller ball applicator. It’s super lightweight and perfect for those who don’t like heavy creams. It’s packed with actives like Undaria and red algae, Caffeine, hyaluronic acid, biomimetic tetrapeptide, and plant extracts to hydrate and soothe the delicate eye area.
5. Cocokind Revitalizing Eye Cream
Best for: General eye area hydration and rejuvenation
Price: $18
Cocokind’s eye cream is a solid choice if you’re looking for a product that focuses on hydration and revitalization. It’s made with natural ingredients like Persian silk tree extract and hibiscus flower acids to brighten and smooth the skin around your eyes.
6. Whamisa Organic Flowers Eye Essence
Best for: Dryness, dullness, and skin texture
Price: $40
If you’re into organic Korean skincare, this eye essence will be your new favorite. It’s 95% organic, using aloe juice and a variety of fermented flowers like chrysanthemum, lotus, and dandelion. This product is great for improving skin texture and dullness, leaving you with a bright and refreshed look. You’ll get 40mls of it.
7. Perricone MD Eyelid Lift Serum
Best for: Fine lines, deep wrinkles, puffiness, and dark circles
Price: $73.20
This serum contains natural ingredients like oat kernel extract and rosemary leaf extract, but it is not certified organic. The formula is designed to be gentle and effective for all skin types. Perricone MD Essential Fx Acyl-Glutathione Eyelid Lift Serum delivers visible results. You’ll notice significant improvements in how your eyelids look – tightening and smoothing of fine lines. Yeah, the eyelid lift serum has a higher price point, but its effectiveness and longevity make it a great investment. I found that a small amount goes a long way, so the product lasts for months. And, it complements other Perricone products beautifully, contributing to a youthful and refreshed look. Gently pat the serum onto your eye area using your ring finger. Apply it both morning and evening, and be sure to keep it out of your eyes.
8. Nourish Organic Eye Treatment with Vitamin C
Best for: Dark circles, puffiness, and dryness
Price: $19.99
This light and creamy under eye cream is rich in Vitamin C, known for skin brightening and helping reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. It is free from dyes, parabens, sulfates, and petrochemicals – and is formulated with certified organic ingredients. Simply squeeze a small amount onto fingertips and gently apply under and around each eye. Finish by patting until fully absorbed. This product is seriously awesome with top-notch ingredients and a great deal. I’ve spent way more on eye creams that come in jars, which aren’t super hygienic even if I wash my hands first. Plus, the price is unbeatable!
9. Alteya Bio Damascena Rose Otto Ageless Eye Cream
Best for: Dryness and Dark circles
Price: $46.27
This 15ml eye cream has quickly become a favorite of mine! It glides on smoothly and has a delightful, subtle rose fragrance. I’ve seen a noticeable difference in the brightness and smoothness around my eyes. While it may not be a miracle worker, it’s definitely the best improvement I’ve experienced in a long time, and I’m thrilled with the results. I wasn’t familiar with the Alteya brand before, but now I’m a devoted fan. The results are both quick and impressive. The jar contains 0.51oz, which might seem small, but a little goes a long way. I apply it twice daily, and the jar will last me quite a while.
10. Brightening Probiotic Caffeine Eye Cream
Best for: Dryness
Price: $48.95
The combination of caffeine and green tea really helps reduce puffiness and firm up the delicate skin under my eyes. I no longer have those annoying bags, and my eyes look naturally refreshed and awake.
What really impressed me is how it brightens and rejuvenates my eyes. The blend of Horseradish Extract, Kojic Acid, Fennel Extract, and Licorice Root works wonders on discoloration and dark circles. My eyes look so much more youthful now.
The probiotics in this cream are a nice touch, balancing the pH and brightening the skin around my eyes. It feels like it enhances my natural beauty. Plus, the vegan formula with Plant-Based Ceramides locks in moisture and strengthens the under-eye area, giving me a radiant glow.
I also noticed that it softens the appearance of crow’s feet and fine lines, leaving my skin smoother and more luminous. Overall, I’m really happy with the results and would definitely recommend it to anyone looking to improve their under-eye area.
Natural & Organic Eye Masks That I Use
Sometimes you need a quick pick-me-up, and eye masks are perfect for that. Here are some of the best natural and organic eye masks that you’ll love:
Best Anti-Aging Eye Mask: Juice Beauty Stem Cellular Instant Eye Lift Algae Mask
Price: $10 for 1 mask
This mask offers a two-step process that combines the STEM CELLULAR™ Activator Fluid with freeze-dried biomatrix algae masks for maximum potency. Made with certified organic ingredients, it reduces puffiness with organic cucumber, white tea, and arnica extracts, and hydrates with hyaluronic acid.
Best Affordable Clean Eye Mask: Grace & Stella Energy Drink Eye Masks
Price: $30 for 24 pairs
These masks work wonders and are budget-friendly. They contain Hydrolyzed Vegetable Protein to firm, Hyaluronic Acid for fine lines, and Chondrus Crispus Powder for dark circles.
Best Hydrating Eye Mask: 100% Pure Bright Eyes Mask
Price: $30 for 6 masks
Made with mostly organic aloe juice, these hydrogel masks are refreshing and packed with Vitamin C, Green Tea, Yerba Mate, and Hyaluronic Acid for a quick hydration boost.
Best Budget Eye Mask: Derma E Hydro Gel Patches
Price: $25 for 60 patches
These thin, jelly-like hydrogel patches offer quick hydration with ingredients like Allantoin, Vitamin C, Niacinamide, Sodium Hyaluronate, Cabbage Lead Extract, Coconut Fruit Extract, and Tomato Fruit Extract.
My conclusion
It isn’t easy to find the best natural and organic eye cream or serum for your particular skincare routine – lots of products out there are just glorified moisturizers anyway. Good thing the ones listed here are packed with active ingredients that address specific concerns like dark circles, wrinkles, and puffiness, from serums to creams, even refreshing eye masks! Seriously, the search is over for most of us. Hey, go ahead and treat your eyes to the special care they deserve!
